Mar 06, · Juveniles should be tried as adults because it helps to show them that there are consequences for their actions. Today’s court systems are outdated and minors commit crimes because they know they will get off easy. If they start actually being punished for the crimes they commit, future crimes could be prevented and the crime rates will lower.5/5(36) Aug 13, · Most people oppose the trial of teens as adults because they fear ruining the future lives of the teen. It is argued that, the teens can be rehabilitated and change their behavior to become productive citizens in the future. Therefore, the punishment should be relatively mild that involves shortened sentences hence in most cases Feb 25, · What are some pros of trying juveniles as adults? It is argued that trying juveniles as adults will decrease crimes committed by the youth. Children may start thinking more carefully about their crimes, knowing they could receive adult sentence/5(30)
Juveniles Should Be Tried as Adults, Essay Example
The topic of juvenile offenders being tried and punished as adults is a very touchy subject. Some people support the idea and many are opposed to it. Suppose two young teens age 14 get into an altercation and one decides to stab the other in the heat of the moment. This teen has committed a crime and should get punished for his or her actions.
The question is whether the youth should get tried and punished in Juvenile Court or Criminal Court as an adult? When children commit crimes such as murder, does that automatically make them adults? This is the question in which supporters ask. Or do children maintain some bits and pieces of childhood and innocence, regardless of the severity of their actions? This is what those in opposition question.
Does one or two years younger than eighteen make much of a difference? Is it fair for one person, just seventeen years of age or younger to be tried in juvenile court, receiving a lesser sentence than someone who is just a few years older who committed the same crime?
I believe juveniles who commit heinous crimes just like adults, should be charged as adults. No one should be exempt from punishment. A crime is a crime and for that reason, juveniles who commit violent crimes should suffer the same consequences. This paper will discuss the history and purpose of the juvenile justice system and the pros and cons of trying juvenile offenders as adults.
Children as young as seven years old, however, could stand trial in criminal court for offenses committed should juveniles be tried as adults essays, if found guilty, could be sentenced to prison or even to death.
The first juvenile court was formed in in Illinois. The juvenile court was created to handle juvenile delinquents based on their adolescence rather than the actual crimes committed. The purpose was to focus on the child or adolescent as a person that was in need of support and not on the action that brought him or her before the court.
In court children were not looked at being guilty, they were judged as someone who made a mistake and committed a dreadful crime, should juveniles be tried as adults essays. The juvenile system was not created to send the youth to prison, should juveniles be tried as adults essays.
It sent them to a training school, a rehabilitation program or reformatory. Juvenile court proceedings were very much relaxed and easygoing. It was not suspenseful like Criminal Court. In Juvenile Court, the decision was usually left to the juvenile court judge. The duty of the judge was to act in the best interest of the child. The normal procedures that were required and available to adults, should juveniles be tried as adults essays, such as the right to an attorney, the right to know the charges brought against one, and the right to trial by jury were considered unnecessary in juvenile court.
Court proceedings for the youth were closed to the public and their records were to remain confidential. During the s and s, the public called for getting tough with juveniles and trying them as adults. Because of an increase to violent crimes committed by juveniles, many started to push for state legal reforms in juvenile justice system, which would punish juveniles tougher for serious crimes, rather than stick to the traditional rehabilitation approach. It is amazing how ancient, archaic, and broken down the juvenile justice system.
Butts, Adele V. Harrell, Pg. Because children are young they get away with murder, should juveniles be tried as adults essays. They get multiple chances to learn from their mistakes, but some commit numerous violent crimes because they know they will get a light sentencing. The youth is wiser than we think. To many teens, getting arrested is cool to them. Many youths are in and out of juvie constantly and they are not learning from their previous mistakes.
It is because the juvenile system is too soft on teens why some choose to take advantage of it. Issues arising from juvenile delinquency proceedings hardly ever come before the U. Supreme Court. Juvenile Offenders and Victims: National Report, National Center for Juvenile Justice. The National Report, National Center for Juvenile Justice describes a series of cases that made juvenile court more like criminal court, but still maintained some differences.
Breed v. Jones U. InGary Jones whom was seventeen years old, was charged with armed robbery. He was adjudicated delinquent on the original charge and two other robberies.
Upon appeal, the U. Should juveniles be tried as adults essays Court ruled that an adjudication in juvenile court, in which a juvenile is found to have violated a criminal statute, is equivalent to a trial in criminal court. In re Winship U. A store employee claimed should juveniles be tried as adults essays have seen Winship running from the scene just before the woman noticed the money was missing; others in the store stated that the employee was not in a position to see the money being taken.
He was adjudicated delinquent and committed to a training school. In the case of McKeiver v. Pennsylvania U. Joseph McKeiver, age sixteen, was charged with robbery, larceny, and receiving stolen goods. He and about twenty to thirty other youth allegedly chased three youth and took twenty-five cents from them. He was adjudicated and placed on probation. Supreme Court found that the due process clause of the Fourteenth amendment did not require jury trials in juvenile court.
As a result, these cases were the start of a change in the juvenile system from when it was first introduced. What are some pros of trying juveniles as adults? It is argued that trying juveniles as adults will decrease crimes committed by the youth. Children may start thinking more carefully about their crimes, knowing they could receive adult sentence. The result of a heinous crime remains the same, no matter who commits it, whether it is an adolescence or an adult. Perpetrators should be held accountable and responsible for their actions.
When kids get punitive sentencing, it acts as a warning to kids who are considering committing crimes. Light sentences do not teach the youth the lesson they need to learn. Kids today are more sophisticated at a younger age; they understand the implications of violence and how to use violent weapons. It is absurd to argue that a modern child, who sees the effect of violence around him in the news every day, does not understand what killing really is.
Charging the youth as adults can possibly help reduce gang related crimes. Gang members tend to use teenagers to commit their crimes because they know that they should juveniles be tried as adults essays receive a lighter sentence than if they were to do it themselves.
It is unfair for gang members to take advantage of young children, but punishing teens as adults for the same crime adults commit will send a message to gang members that they can no longer use teens to do their dirty work. Many experts believe that trying juveniles as adults will only make matters worse. They feel that the juvenile prison system can help kids turn their lives around.
Instead of trying should juveniles be tried as adults essays as adults, rehabilitation helps to give the youth a second chance. Why rehabilitation? It is said that teenagers who are released from juvenile prison is far less likely to commit a crime than someone who was released from an adult facility.
Another point that some argue is that children do not have the intellectual or moral capacity to understand the consequences of their actions. Recent Longitudinal neuroimaging studies demonstrate that the adolescent brain continues to mature well into the 20s. Johnson, S. Adolescent Maturity and the Brain: The Promise and Pitfalls of Neuroscience Research in Adolescent Health Policy.
The Journal of Adolescent Health?? In addition, children should not be able to get access to deadly weapons and adults who make guns easily accessible to them should be held accountable as well. How can we prevent juveniles from committing serious crimes that will land them in jail? Two ways I feel juvenile crimes can be prevented and keep teens from becoming incarcerated are to make access to handguns less accessible to the youth and to improve education for youth in poor communities.
I believe these two options will be a start to keep the youth out trouble and to prevent them from being charged as adults when they commit serious crimes. Should Juveniles Be Tried as Adults?. Should Juveniles Be Tried as Adults? com, Feb 25, Accessed October 7, comFeb Should Juveniles be Tried as Adults? Did you like this example?
A professional writer will make a clear, mistake-free paper for you! Stuck on ideas? Struggling with a concept? Get help with your assigment. Leave your email and we will send a sample to you. Email Send me the sample. Thank you!
Video Essay: Should Juveniles be Tried as Adults?
, time: 5:18Should Juveniles Be Tried As Adults - Free Essay Example
Feb 25, · What are some pros of trying juveniles as adults? It is argued that trying juveniles as adults will decrease crimes committed by the youth. Children may start thinking more carefully about their crimes, knowing they could receive adult sentence/5(30) Mar 06, · Juveniles should be tried as adults because it helps to show them that there are consequences for their actions. Today’s court systems are outdated and minors commit crimes because they know they will get off easy. If they start actually being punished for the crimes they commit, future crimes could be prevented and the crime rates will lower.5/5(36) Aug 13, · Most people oppose the trial of teens as adults because they fear ruining the future lives of the teen. It is argued that, the teens can be rehabilitated and change their behavior to become productive citizens in the future. Therefore, the punishment should be relatively mild that involves shortened sentences hence in most cases
No comments:
Post a Comment